Have you ever arrived at a crash scene and had something unexpected happen to you
while securing a vehicle? Does your training lead you to believe that disconnecting the
negative cable on a battery removes all power from a vehicle? A simple check may
prove you wrong and could protect you from injury!
An early result from fire safety research being conducted under a settlement agreement
between General Motors Corporation (GM) and the U.S. Department of Transportation
(DOT) has identified important information that the National Highway Traffic Safety
Administration (NHTSA) believes may be extremely valuable to initial responders, but
may easily be overlooked.
During a recent crash test conducted by GM, simulating an impact by one vehicle to the
left front corner of another vehicle, with a closing speed of 65 mph, an interesting and
unexpected result occurred. After the vehicle came to rest, the fire department
approached the vehicle to inspect for post-collision fire. Fire officials noted that the
battery had broken open and smoke was rising from the battery. The fire officials
disconnected the negative battery cable and thought that the vehicle was secured--that
the vehicle's electrical system was no longer receiving power from the battery.
Several minutes later, however, an observer noticed that the vehicle's taillights
appeared to be "on." Since the test was being conducted outdoors, it was first assumed
that this was merely a reflection from the sunlight. It turned out, however, that the
taillights indeed were still "on." The fire department was asked how this could be
possible when the vehicle's battery had been disconnected.
A careful post-collision "tear-down" revealed that a sheet-metal screw in the vehicle's
power distribution box had penetrated the side of the battery during the collision,
creating a circuit for the electricity to flow. Even though the battery was severely
damaged during the crash and three of its six internal cells had lost battery acid, the
battery still generated approximately 7.5 volts. The power and heat generated by the
electrical current flowing through this unfused circuit were sufficient to light the vehicle's
taillights and to start a fire in the vehicle.
The message to initial responders is that a simple inspection of a vehicle during the
"securing" procedure should include a check for anything out of the ordinary. Is the
vehicle's electrical system still receiving power even though the battery has been
disconnected? (Radio on? Dome light? Wipers? Outside lights? Dash lights?
Blower motor?). All of these should be "off" if the battery is no longer connected.
If there is any evidence that power from the battery is still running any part of the
electrical system, check that the negative cable has been disconnected from the
battery. Then, carefully disconnect the positive cable at the battery. Use care not
to touch any metal part of the chassis with the cable or your tools, to minimize
the risk of creating a spark. Check the electrical system again to make sure it is
not receiving power.
Taking these precautions is especially important for initial responders during extrication
of victims in air bag equipped vehicles when the air bags have not deployed. Although
most frontal crashes that are severe enough to break open a battery (such as occurred
in this crash test) are also severe enough to deploy an air bag, all precautions should be
taken to ensure that an air bag does not deploy during extrication.
Because the results of this crash test were unexpected, NHTSA would like to receive
information from initial responders about similar situations they may have experienced.
In particular, the agency would be interested in receiving information about fires, shock
hazards, or similar occurrences involving vehicles that were believed to be safely
secured, as well as information about experiences of initial responders with hard-to-
reach batteries. If you have information, please contact Mr. Carl Ragland at NHTSA on
(202) 366-4728 or through the Internet on CARL.RAGLAND@NHTSA.DOT.GOV. This
information could be very helpful for future research and education efforts.