In an article entitled "Effects of Aging on Older Drivers' Travel
Characteristics" and published in Transportation Research Record 1438,
Rahim F. Benekohal, Richard M. Michaels, Eunjai Shim, and Paulo
T. V. Resende reviewed the results of an Illinois statewide study
focused on driving characteristics of older people. Report data
suggested that, as the number of older drivers in the United
States increases, older drivers' reduced visual and cognitive
performance on driving-related tasks should be considered in
highway safety design and operation.
According to Benekohal, et al., 12.6 percent (31 million) of the
population of the United States was 65 or older in 1990; this
number will increase to 21.1 percent (64 million) by 2030.
Showing this trend, the number of licensed drivers age 65 and
older had increased by more than 50 percent since 1969. However,
highway design criteria reflect the performance characteristics
of younger drivers, providing less margin of safety for older
drivers.
To study travel characteristics and driving changes occurring
with aging, researchers mailed a survey to 850 randomly selected
drivers in Illinois over 65 years of age. Nearly 78 percent, 664
drivers, returned the completed survey. About 85 percent of
respondents were 75 years or older, although only a few drivers
were over 90. In addition, the research team conducted four
focus groups with older drivers from both rural and urban areas
to add detail to mail survey findings. In analyzing data
Benekohal, et al., divided drivers into four age categories: 66
to 68, 69 to 72, 73 to 76, and 77 and older. They found some
statistical differences between these categories as well as
between male and female drivers. The article gave data results
for nine categories:
- Travel frequency
- Road type
- Trip recency
- Trip purpose
- Trip length
- Vehicle miles traveled
- Travel time
- Conditions avoided
- Driving difficulty.
Travel Frequency: Since 70 percent of older drivers reported
using their cars at least five days a week and 42 percent said
they used their cars daily, survey results showed older drivers
do use their cars regularly. However, as the age of the driver
increased, the frequency of use decreased. Also, male drivers
were more likely than females to drive a car seven days a week--
50 percent compared to 32 percent.
Road Type: Seventy-five percent of older drivers drove mostly in
a town or city, while 16 percent reported using the highways. As
the age of the driver increased, urban road use increased. The
authors cited examples of this tendency: "23 percent of the 66-
to 68-year age group use highways compared with 7 percent in the
77+ age group, and 66 percent of the same age group compared with
78 percent of the 77+ age group drive on urban roads" (p. 94).
Trip Recency: When asked about their most recent driving trip,
nearly 69 percent of males responded that they drove either that
day or the day before. Only 19 percent of females said they
drove that day or the day before. When asked about their second
most recent trip, 49 percent said that trip had been the day
before and 20 percent said it had been two days before. Results
indicated about 15 percent of older drivers drove a car more than
once a day. These figures helped determine average annual
vehicle miles traveled for older drivers.
Trip Purpose: Forty-nine percent of survey respondents said their
most recent trip was for grocery and personal shopping. Other
reasons for travel were: personal business (15 percent),
recreational or social trips (12 percent), going to work (8
percent), and medical or dental appointments (7 percent). Seven
percent reported their trips were for more than one purpose. As
driver age increased, frequency of work and recreational or
social trips decreased. Frequency of grocery or other shopping
trips and multipurpose trips increased with age. Also, more
female drivers said their trips were for grocery and other
shopping, while more males identified medical or dental
appointments and recreational or social trips as their travel
purposes.
Trip Length: To avoid skewing reported results, researchers
computed average trip length based on a systematic deletion of
extremely large trip lengths. When 95 percent of the data were
used, the average trip length was 11.4 miles. The average trip
length of drivers over 77 was considerably shorter.
Vehicle Miles Traveled: Researchers calculated average vehicle
miles traveled based on trip length and trip frequency data
reported on their survey. Correcting for extremely large trip
lengths by using only 95 percent of the data, Benekohal, et al.,
found that the average distance survey respondents drove per year
was 7,522 miles. Nearly half of the respondents felt they
presently were driving less than they did ten years ago.
However, 37 percent felt they were driving as much now as they
did ten years ago, and 14 percent felt they were driving more
now.
Travel Time: While 87 percent of older drivers said they
frequently drove during off-peak hours (9 a.m. to 3 p.m.), 56
percent also drove during the afternoon peak hours of 3 p.m. to 6
p.m. Over one-fourth drove during the morning peak hours of 6
a.m. to 9 a.m. and during the evening and night hours of 6 p.m.
to midnight. Less than 1 percent, however, said they drove after
midnight. A significantly larger number of women than men said
they drove during off-peak hours (9 a.m. to 3 p.m.).
Conditions Avoided: Saying they drove most when conditions were
safest, older drivers felt they were most likely to avoid driving
in snow and ice. They also avoided peak-hour travel, night
driving, and driving in the rain--in that order. As driver age
increased, the order changed to avoiding peak-hour traffic, ice
and snow, and night driving.
Driving Difficulty: When survey respondents considered all
factors to compare the difficulty of driving now with ten years
ago, about 63 percent responded that driving difficulty was about
the same. On the other hand, 26 percent felt driving was more
difficult for them now, and only 11 percent reported driving now
was less difficult. However, when researchers asked questions
about such circumstances as nighttime driving or making left
turns, respondents said they were having more difficulty with
these specific situations than they had previously. Benekohal,
et al., theorized, "They may have had to drive in more complex
driving conditions (e.g., work trips) when they were younger, but
now they have more freedom to select less complex driving
conditions (less crowded road and off-peak hours)" (p. 96).
Focus groups brought out a few points that survey results did not
emphasize. Most older drivers avoided nighttime trips; however,
some preferred night driving because of lighter traffic and
higher speeds. Both urban and rural drivers participating in
focus groups expressed concern about managing complex traffic
environments. Older drivers said they were adapting their
driving behavior to adjust for sensory, cognitive, and motor
changes they were experiencing. To compensate for changes in
their driving capabilities, older drivers chose when and where
they drove. Restrictions were self-imposed, and older drivers
seemed to find such adaptive behavior "quite acceptable" (p. 97).
They did report increased anxiety about driving and a feeling
they were not able to keep up with younger drivers. Focus group
participants emphasized driving is more than a necessity for
older drivers--it is a measure of their freedom.