The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) funded research conducted by the
University of Maryland to find out if ignition interlock devices reduced the recidivism
rate of repeat violators of drinking-and-driving laws. Ignition interlocks attach to a
vehicle's ignition system and require that the driver pass a breath alcohol test before
being able to start the engine. An article entitled "Ignition Interlocks Help Curb
Violations Among Repeat DUI/DWI Offenders" in the May 10, 1997 Status Report
described the results of that study.
Previous studies of the effect of ignition interlocks on repeat DUI/DWI offenses were
inconclusive because study groups had not been randomly assigned. For the present
study, Maryland researchers used a sample group of 1,380 repeat offenders of
drinking-and-driving laws who had received treatment and were eligible to have their
driving privileges reinstated. They randomly assigned members of the group "to either
a continuing treatment program or a treatment and interlock program." Offenders
participating in the interlock program received restricted licenses allowing them to drive
a vehicle only if it were equipped with an ignition interlock.
Results reported a year later revealed that only 2.4 percent of those repeat offenders
assigned to the interlock program had committed an alcohol-related traffic violation.
The violation rate for the control group was 6.7 percent. Kenneth Beck, one of the
researchers and a professor of health education at the University of Maryland,
reported, "This was a statistically significant difference and indicated that being in an
interlock program reduced the risk of an alcohol traffic violation within the first year by
about 65 percent."
Researchers felt the ignition interlock program had fewer drawbacks that putting people
in jail or impounding their vehicles. Moreover, offenders whose driving privileges are
suspended or revoked often keep driving. Compared to these methods, the ignition
interlock appears to be a more effective countermeasure to repeat drinking-and-driving
violations--at least during the first year. Drivers involved in this study could request
that interlocks be removed after a year, and most made that request. Researchers will
continue to keep track of alcohol-related violations committed by the study group for
another year to see if their lower repeat-offense rate continues.
To get a copy of the study report ("The Effects of Alcohol Ignition Interlock License
Restrictions on Multiple Alcohol Offenders: A Randomized Trial in Maryland" by K.H.
Beck, W.J. Rauch, and E.A. Baker), write to: Publications, Insurance Institute for
Highway Safety, 1005 North Glebe Road, Arlington, Virginia 22201.